Three representative comments from MMSA Stories readers on Jim's comments about "how old?" (see prior posting)
--------------------------------------------------
Dear Cal,
I'm not unexperienced in these areas either yet to my mind a boy is NEVER to old to be spanked when he deserves to be. It's as simple as that! Yes, the humiliation he feels when you make him strip and wait for it is more intense when he's older and it should be. I don't give a healthy _d_a_m_n_ how embarrassed and humiliated he is when I strip and spank my boys cause if they don't like it they simply don't have to misbehave in the first place. College kids these days screw away their education and we're suppose to pay anyway? Bull _s_h_i_t_! Around here I've got a good strong leather strap hanging on a nail behind the hall closet door and my boys all know that if they come in later than I tell them to or their grades aren't good, I don't care about their age or their excuses. Don't even want to hear them. They're going to be send down to the basement and I'm going to beat me a bare ass down there 'til they learn how to behave. I don't like to beat them, but you can be _d_a_m_n_ed sure I will and they know it too. Consequently, they are real good around here and they rarely give me any trouble. A good ass whipping will do that for you. No question about it and age has nothing to do with it.
Pat
---------------------------------------------------
Dear Cal,
On spanking a boy regardless of his age, it makes no difference when he needs correction.
However, I would enjoy discussing this more with you and posit that the simple spanking that Jim, who wrote, gets may be less than he really needs. I too have a boy whom I am proud to mentor and for whom I serve as his disciplinarian. A boy responds best if the spanking is severe and turned into a whimpering teary event over the lap. Of course he learns best with regular and dependable lessons on his bare ass. That boy, Jim, sounded like he is not disciplined well enough, regularly enough, and absent any dependable ritual.
Ritual, yes, ritual. That Bob needs to set a firm time each day, especially if Jim is still a student and having trouble seeing the importance of studying, and I would suggest at the end of the day or first thing every morning on weekends. Jim should be REQUIRED to stripped and completely bare and standing in a corner at the appointed hour. His work or "journal" I think he called it, should be on Bob's desk and a paddle and strap should be on that desk also. Let Jim stand there with his nose in that corner and his ass waiting for Bob's decision after a half hour or more of looking at whatever's on his desk. At a minimum, spank him to keep his ass focused and him motivated to work hard. If anything on his work that night gives Bob any concern at all and even if it is only a misspelled word or poor grammar, paddle him hard and he will learn quickly. Anything else not right during his day and that is what the strap is for. No discussion, none of this tenderness you sometimes write about, only crystal dependable discipline each and every day at a pre-set time.
After that, Bob should make Jim re-do any errors in any paperwork or any work he forgot to do or did not have time to do that day that he was told to have done. No clothes permitted after a spanking. Let his red and sore bare ass be visible for the rest of the day or evening and that means no matter who happens to be over or visiting. Let Jim experience some problems of his own making. And if he does anything Bob does not like after that, spank him again and on the spot no matter who is there to see him get it. Hard firm discipline dependable and always there – that is a ritual that an older boy needs starting with Jim.
I am right on this point. I practice what I preach exactly as above. It works far better than this now-and-again philosophy Bob sounds like he has. That's BS. Jim's asking for it for sure and for real. Bob's the wimp.
Let's talk.
Brian
---------------------------------------------------
. . . wow like bare? 16, 17 max, but ok depends on the guy and what he did, but jim was awesome and i felt so close 2 him right there with what he said for me 2 i am with him and would like 2 meet him. ok its nice sometimes 2 when u know someone's cares enough 2 want 2 guide u. when over every time it makes u feel confessional is done and that's great ok but not 2 often. then ok maybe 19 but guess u will wright back and tell me i am wrong but anyway i don't get no choice cause i am older and ok get spanked sometime. so how old do you think really? kevin